A History of Christmas Food: From Boar’s Head to Candy Canes

Christmas is always a time to feel cheer and joy. We look forward to sitting down to meals with our community and family. This traditional holiday reflects culture, wealth, religion, and storytelling. The dishes we share today are the result of evolving traditions, trade, and political history.

As we gather around the table, sharing traditional food, we remember the significance of each dish and its place in our festive celebrations.

Grab your eggnog latte and let’s journey through Christmas food across the ages. As you sip away, we will explore how this holiday feast became what it is today.

Bread, Wine, and Simplicity: The Earliest Christmas Foods

In the first centuries of Christianity, Christmas was simple and sparse. Sermons, prayers, and the Eucharist were central to the day. Bread and wine were the only Christmas food; these symbolized unity and devotion.

No feasts, no puddings, and definitely no lavish desserts! The early church frowned on excessive celebration. Less was more.

*This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. I earn from qualifying purchases. Thank you for supporting this site and helping me keep ancient food stories alive. Learn more.
We are also a partner with Stay22. To learn more about how they handle data and tracking, you can visit their Privacy Policy Page.*

Medieval Christmas: The Showmanship Feast Fit for Royalty

Christmas food during the Medieval and Renaissance periods was elaborate displays of wealth and power. Food was theater. The aristocracy competed to outdo one another. Increasingly extravagant presentations trumped spectacle as much as taste.

Roasted peacocks were laboriously re-dressed in their iridescent plumage, presented lifelike, complete with tails spread wide. Swans also boasted gilded beaks and fire-breathing effects created by igniting alcohol-soaked cloth. The boar’s head entered the room with a grand ceremony. Adorned with fruits and greenery, the dish was the centerpiece of the feast.

Each dish was a spectacle, but ultimately, it was the Christmas food that brought people together.

The most dramatic food was the “surprise pies”. Live birds or small animals would burst out when the crust was cut. Hence, the inspiration for the song “four and twenty blackbirds baked in a pie.” 

The lavish use of costly spices, such as cinnamon and cloves, showcased the host’s prosperity and extensive trade network. Such carefully orchestrated displays were designed to impress guests and affirm the host’s place in society.

The Real Mince Pie: Meat and Suet

Understanding the origins of these recipes enriches our appreciation for contemporary Christmas food.

Medieval and early modern mince pies bore little resemblance to today’s sweet treats. Once called “shrid pies” (from “shred,” meaning finely chopped meat), the base of this dish was a savory mixture of mutton or beef, suet. Dried fruits, expensive spices, and sometimes hard-boiled eggs were added for richness and texture.

This combination of meat and fruit showcased medieval taste for sweet-savory pairings. The heavy use of spices served both to preserve the filling and to display wealth. The oblong shape represented Christ’s manger. Mince pies are a Christmas food staple that spans across all social classes.

The gradual shift toward sweeter, meatless treats began in the 18th century as sugar became more affordable. Tastes evolved, eventually eliminating the meat (though suet often remains). What we eat today is the evolution of a once-hearty main course.

Frumenty to Christmas Pudding

This transition in recipes illustrates how Christmas food has adapted over time.

Christmas pudding’s ancestor was frumenty. This medieval Christmas food was a porridge cooked with cracked or hulled wheat, boiled in milk or broth. Wealthy households enriched it with meat like mutton or beef (sometimes even porpoise). Dried fruits, spices like cinnamon and saffron, and wine added the luxurious touch.

It was traditionally eaten as a meal before Christmas festivities or served with venison at grand medieval feasts. In the 16th and 17th centuries, sweet ingredients turned frumenty into plum pudding. Plum meant any dried fruit, particularly raisins and currants. The Puritans thought it frivolous and banned it in 1664. King George I restored it to the Christmas table in 1714.

It wasn’t until the Victorian era that Christmas pudding became the dessert we all know. The dense, dark treacle is long-cooked and steamed in a basin rather than boiled in cloth. The theatrical flaming presentation is said to represent Christ’s passion. A Victorian custom of hiding silver coins or charms for luck transformed a medieval survival food into a symbol of Christmas.

This evolution reflects a broader transformation in society’s relationship with Christmas food.

Christmas Foods Were Once Illegal

Today, we enjoy the freedom to celebrate with Christmas food without fear of reprisal.

In June 1647, England’s Puritan Parliament abolished Christmas. The holiday was viewed as too Catholic. The word “Christmas” included “mass”, which was too pagan. December 25 had been chosen centuries earlier to coincide with Roman Saturnalia celebrations.

Soldiers broke up church services and suppressed public festivities. In London, patrols confiscated food for Christmas feasts. The day was to be observed as a fast rather than a celebration.

Mince pies were condemned as symbols of Christmas excess. In 1644, eating mince pies was illegal on Christmas Day because the holiday coincided with a mandated national fast.

The bans sparked widespread resistance. Pro-Christmas riots erupted, and protesters temporarily seized control of entire towns.

Across the Atlantic, Puritan authorities took an even harder line. In 1659, the Massachusetts Bay Colony made the celebration of Christmas a criminal offense. This ban remained in effect for 22 years, until it was repealed in 1681.

Gingerbread Fairytales

The custom of making gingerbread houses, or lebkuchenhäusle, traces back to Germany. Medieval monks were already creating ginger-spiced cakes by the 15th century. A century later, German bakers began crafting houses out of gingerbread cookies.

This tradition gained widespread popularity in Germany after the Brothers Grimm published the fairy tale “Hansel and Gretel” in 1812. The houses were assembled from gingerbread pieces shaped as walls and roofs, held together with thick icing, making a charming Christmas decoration. Wealthy families embellished their houses with silver and gold foil, while others used simple white icing.

German immigrants brought this beloved custom to America, where it became a staple. By 1909, Good Housekeeping magazine was recommending gingerbread houses as an activity for children’s parties, solidifying its place as a popular Christmas tradition.

Turkey Takes the Crown

Many centuries before the turkey became the Christmas roast, Europeans dined on goose and boar. Turkeys arrived in Europe from the New World in the 1500s but didn’t dominate Christmas tables until the 19th century, when mass farming made them more affordable.

Charles Dickens helped cement the tradition with “A Christmas Carol“. The turkey became the signature of holiday stardom.

My Middle Eastern Spiced Turkey Rub Recipe

My ancestry is from the Middle East. Here’s a spice blend I created inspired by my family’s ancient culinary traditions. I add ingredients like cinnamon, cloves, nutmeg, and ginger to give my turkey a different spicy flavor.

Ingredients

• 1 tbsp ground cinnamon
• 2½ tsp ground nutmeg
• 1 tbsp ground turmeric
• 1 tbsp ground sumac
• 1 tbsp dried oregano
• 1 tsp ground cloves
• 1½ tbsp paprika
• 2 tsp chili powder
• 1½ tbsp kosher salt
• 2 tsp freshly ground black pepper
• 1 tbsp ground ginger
• 8–10 garlic cloves, finely minced or grated
• Juice of 2 large lemons
• 1 onion chopped fine
• 5–6 tbsp olive oil (optional, but recommended

Instructions

1. In a bowl, mix cinnamon, nutmeg, turmeric, sumac, oregano, cloves, paprika, chili powder, salt, pepper, and ginger. I make this in advance and store it in a tight container.
2. In a separate bowl, whisk the garlic with lemon juice and olive oil to form a thick paste.
3. Stir the spice blend into the garlic mixture until fully combined.
4. Pat the turkey completely dry. Rub generously over the skin, under the skin where possible, and inside the cavity.
5. Cover and refrigerate for 12–24 hours. Remove from the fridge 45–60 minutes before roasting.

A Sugar Stick Keeps Children Quiet

Candy canes are a holiday fixture. But the popular legend for candy cane dates back to 17th-century Germany where a choirmaster used sugar sticks to keep children quiet during long nativity services. The familiar “shepherd’s hook” was added to represent the shepherds visiting Jesus. The religious symbol was conceived to calm church board complaints about indulgent sweets. The candy became common in the 1900s with the addition of red stripes and peppermint flavoring solidifying their Christmas identity.  So, while it’s a “legend,” it’s the widely accepted story explaining the candy cane’s unique form and connection to Christmas. The German tradition later spread to America, becoming a Christmas staple.

These sweet treats are now intertwined with the essence of Christmas food, cherished by young and old alike.

A Feast That Keeps Evolving

Christmas cuisine has never stopped evolving throughout the ages. Every dish on our modern table carries a story and a bit of history. Tales that are humble, sometimes extravagant, but always delicious.

Our evolving tastes continue to shape what we consider to be essential Christmas food.

With every generation, we add new chapters and new flavors.

Each meal shared reflects our individual stories, all united by the theme of Christmas food.

Explore more in our Food Spotlights or subscribe to our newsletter for weekly stories and recipes inspired by history.

Through these dishes, we celebrate the enduring love for Christmas food that spans generations.

Note to my readers: My research draws on travel experiences, books, and, sometimes, AI tools. I love using my own photos whenever possible, but occasionally I include stock or AI-generated images to help illustrate the story.