Afternoon Tea Existed Before the Scone. So What Changed?

As a British national, I grew up with scones. This delicate pastry followed us to Venezuela to become the star of my grandmother’s afternoon teas.

I remember enjoying the round cake (with currants for an authentic taste) with family and friends. There was always a debate about what comes first: jam or clotted cream? (Keep reading to find out how this fun argument started.) However, the most significant takeaway was the community that developed around the afternoon tea.

What Is a Scone?

A bread, a cake; what is it? Scones are typically round or triangular, with a crumbly yet tender texture. They are plain or flavored with currants, cheese, or dried fruit.

Baked with flour, butter, sugar, and milk, their unique texture makes them different. Not a cake, not bread, it’s a scone.

Scones date way back, much further than you’d think. 

*This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a commission at no cost to you. Learn more.*

Where Did Scones Come From?

Did you know scones have been around since the early 1500s? These treats first popped up in Scotland. The earliest known mention comes from none other than Scottish poet Gavin Douglas. In 1513, while translating Virgil’s Aeneid, he dropped the word “scone” into literary history. While scones are now beloved across the British Isles, the Scots were the first to put them on the map!

The Scots used oats in the original version. The cakes were shaped into a large round shape and cut into four or six wedges. They were then griddle-baked over an open fire. Today’s versions are made with flour and baked in the oven.

Over time, the recipe evolved, becoming more refined as ingredients and techniques improved. By the 18th century, afternoon tea had gained prominence in Britain. The Victorian era enjoyed increased availability of refined flour and sugar. Scones became a popular teatime treat. That’s when the English cream tea stole the spotlight! A tasty little ritual where scones dress up with clotted cream and jam, and head to the royal garden party.

Scones Take Center Stage at the Royal Tea Party

Anna, the Duchess of Bedford, a close friend of Queen Victoria’s, suffered from hunger pangs. Rightfully so! At the time, only two meals were served daily: breakfast and dinner. The gap between meals was not sustainable. 

She called for a light snack at 4 pm. You guessed it, it included a scone.

This little indulgence soon evolved into a social occasion. Anna would invite friends to join her, and the ritual went viral among the aristocracy. By the late 19th century, afternoon tea had become a fashionable staple of British haute cuisine. Fine china, silver tea services, and elegantly set parlors, what a charming experience.

What Goes On First—Cream Or Jam?

Ah, the age-old delicious debate! Even though each side swore their way was best, in my opinion, both are delicious. There are no “rights or wrongs” unless you are from Cornwall, where it’s jam first, clotted cream on top. In Devon, it’s cream first, then jam. Try both… I like the cream on the bottom!

How to Eat a Scone: Customs and Etiquette

Scones are a beloved part of the British afternoon tea tradition, often served with clotted cream and jam. But if you’re unsure of the proper etiquette, you’re not alone. Here’s how to enjoy this classic treat politely and correctly:

1. Scones Are for Afternoon Tea: Traditionally, scones are served during afternoon tea (around 3:30–5 PM), not breakfast. They’re eaten leisurely, alongside a cuppa tea with a spot of milk.
2. Don’t Use a Knife to Cut a Scone: Never slice a scone in half with a knife. Instead, gently break it apart with your hands. The scone should split naturally into two halves.
3. Cream or Jam First? There’s no “wrong” way—just stick to one method per scone half.
4. Use a Spreader, Not Your Spoon: Use the designated spreader knife (not your teaspoon) to apply cream and jam to each bite-sized portion as you go, not all at once.
5. Eat With Your Hands: Eating a scone with your fingers is acceptable. In this case, don’t use a knife or fork. Once dressed, pick it up and eat away. It’s perfectly acceptable and expected.
6. Mind Your Tea Etiquette: Hold the cup by the handle, and avoid looping your finger through it. Please don’t raise your pinky. Stir your tea without clinking the spoon against the cup.

Victorian Scone Recipe (circa 1850s–1890s)

Here’s a traditional Victorian-era scone recipe, in keeping with 19th-century Victorian baking. Scones were more austere than today’s buttery, sweet versions, but still delicious. You can always add butter!

Ingredients (makes about 6-8 scones):

• 1 lb (about 4 cups) of fine white flour
• 1 oz (2 tablespoons) of butter or dripping
• 1/2 pint (1 cup) of milk or buttermilk
• 1/2 teaspoon of bicarbonate of soda (or pearlash in earlier versions)
• 1 teaspoon cream of tartar (or use 1 tbsp of baking powder instead of soda & tartar)
• A pinch of salt

Victorian Additions:

• A tablespoon of sugar and a handful of currants or raisins

Preparation Adapted from 19th-Century Texts

Preheat your oven to a moderate heat — about 375°F (190°C). Sift together the flour, salt, bicarbonate of soda, and cream of tartar. Rub the butter into the flour mixture until it resembles fine breadcrumbs. Make a well in the center and gradually pour in the milk, mixing until a soft but not sticky dough forms. Turn the dough onto a lightly floured pastry board and pat or roll it out to about 3/4 inch thick. Cut into rounds. They didn’t have fancy tools back then, but we have cookie cutters now. Place on a floured baking sheet or a hot griddle, and bake for 10–15 minutes until golden and puffed. Serve warm, with jam and clotted cream.

Historical Notes

• Scones were once baked on a griddle in hearth ovens or cast-iron plates before the widespread adoption of domestic ovens.
• Recipes varied between regions. Scots scones were made with oat flour and without leavening.
• If cooking is not your thing, try this instant mix. You can still serve scones at tea.
  

High Tea NO-NO’s

• NO dunking
• NO butter on a scone served with cream and jam.
• NO knife and fork unless it’s part of a formal dining setting.

Other Interesting Facts about Scones

Today’s scones are often featured at Mother’s Day teas, easter brunches, and wedding showers. In Scotland, oat-based scones are sometimes part of Burns Night suppers.

Modern twists on scones include savory varieties with cheese, chives, or bacon, as well as vegan and gluten-free options. Mini scones are also served at coffee shops, accompanied by sweet toppings like lemon curd, honey, or Nutella.

Bakeries across the world offer their take on this traditional treat, showing the scone’s global popularity.

The scone carries centuries of culinary heritage. Its touch of everyday elegance earned it a place on the historical table. The simplest pleasures often have the richest histories.

Scone Culture around the World

Today, the scone remains a beloved snack steeped in history and tradition.

Scones are not just food, they’re an experience! In the UK, the Devon “Cream Tea” symbolizes refinement and hospitality. This high tea ritual includes scones served with clotted cream and jam alongside a cup of tea. The Australians and New Zealanders have their version of “Devonshire tea.” Served at community events and country fairs. Meanwhile, in the US, scones are sweeter, denser, and eaten for breakfast with a cup of coffee.